Skip to main content

The New Media Tax : Taxing You For What You Don't Use

It has been revealed that when the current TV Licence contract expires, Fine Gael aims to introduce a new tax on media devices such as phones, laptops, and tablets. This is an even more unfair form of taxation than the current TV licence, which basically taxes you for having the ability to watch RTÉ, whether you watch it or not.

While many make the argument that the TV licence is merely supplementing the enormous wages of many within the state broadcaster, the tax also goes towards producing Irish programmes and films. Without the revenue generated from the licence fee many of these would never make it to either the big or small screens.

Placing another tax on devices such as laptops and phones will be a much more unfair practice as technology allows for a tax to be placed on those who use the state broadcasters online service, RTÉ Player. The fact the Fine Gael didn't look at methods of generating state-media revenue through a membership service, shows that this is merely another attempt to take more money from the ordinary taxpayer. Using the same model as Netflix, Amazon prime, and YouTube, would have exclusively targeted those who watch RTÉ for the new charge.

If RTÉ Player required membership, the cost of which would reflect the current licence fee, then people would have a choice on whether or not they want to pay for RTÉ, a choice not afforded to TV owners since RTÉ is a basic channel. Why this isn't being done, is because I would imagine very few people would sign up for RTÉ at €160 per year, when Netflix is just €96 per year for a basic account. There is simply no comparison between the two.

Rather than placing another tax on people who predominantly don't use the service (10% of people don't own a TV and a further 12% of households are unaccounted for), the government should focus on modernising the state broadcaster in order to compete on an online platform. If RTÉ Player allowed you to watch every Irish movie ever made and every episode of every Irish series, I imagine a lot more people would sign up to that service. But while RTÉ Player lacks an archive, and RTÉ lacks varied programming and up to date series, the licence fee will be seen as just another way to get money from the taxpayer.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What's The Beef With Beef ?

The Irish Beef Industry has been going through turbulent times recently, most notably because of the proposed Mercosur deal and the prices farmers receive for their cattle. We haven't even reached Brexit yet, and are still weeks out from the latest withdrawal deadline, and beef farmers are at their wits end. But how has it got to this and can farmers cope if there is a no-deal Brexit? Farmers' incomes are under threat, not just because of the reasons outlined above, but also because of the threat to grants which keep small and medium farms in business. The recent EU elections have seen the status quo remain in the European Parliament, with parties of the right keeping their large dominance of the union. There has been some debate surrounding the EU's agricultural plan over the course of the previous five year parliament, particularly regarding the EU's farm subsidy. Now that the elections are over, the EU government could proceed with plans which could see a standard ...

A 2023 Election Not To Be Ruled Out

  With the Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Green Party coalition now entering its third year of a maximum five-year term, many are of the opinion that the trio will ride out the rather undesirable polling figures and wait until the last possible moment to call another general election. Another common opinion is that an election will be called in the second half of 2024, how late in that half dependent on the results of the European and Local elections in May of that year. Both valid points, particularly the latter; a bumper budget in October, semi-decent canvassing weather, and pre-empting the inevitable winter healthcare crisis, all make for a workable scenario for the government parties. However, strategically speaking, taking those points and applying them to October 2023 may make more sense for Martin, Varadkar, and Ryan, should they be willing to gamble their final year of the term for the prospects of another five-year stint running Leinster House. Despite current polling having ...

Schrodinger’s Election: Can an election be both good and bad at the same time?

  Two elections took place in Ireland last Friday (Three in Limerick, which also had its first Mayoral Election), but you would be forgiven for thinking that there were in fact four or more. Depending on who you asked, a variety of parties had both a good and bad day at the polls. Unlike Schrodinger’s Cat, the parties remain very much alive, though some more alive than others, with none actually licking their wounds. We knew much of the results of the local elections by Sunday evening, apart from the epic count in Newbridge which saw four re-counts and neither candidate involved being elected. They key result, which we knew on Saturday night, was the national result. By the time the weekend came to an end, we knew that there was a correlation between the local and EU results, in terms of party polling at least. Sinn Féin’s Michelle Gildernew MP conceded a little early, but was quick to change her mind and put herself back in contention for a seat, which she was. Fine Gael leade...