Skip to main content

Recall and No Confidence

 


By the time you are reading this, it is likely that California Governor Gavin Newsom will either have survived a recall election, or will have been removed as Governor. But the timing of the election, the same day as Irish Foreign Affairs Minister Simon Coveney faces what is almost certain to be an unsuccessful motion of no confidence, and it begs the question, ‘Should Ireland have a recall process?’

For those unaware of the process, following incompetence or scandal (Governor Newsom was caught breaking his own COVID rules, sound familiar?), the minimum of 12% of the California electorate signed a petition to hold a recall election, which is composed of two parts.

Firstly will Newsom stay or go, which requires 50% approval (he was elected with 62% of the vote), and if the electorate choose for him to go, then Part II of the ballot will come into effect, who will replace him?

A motion of no confidence usually requires the government of the day to turn against one of their own, whereas a recall gives the power to the people of that representative’s constituency. The process of course could do with a little tweaking, such as a petition requirement of somewhere between 30%-50% of registered voters, and perhaps just one ballot paper presented in a by-election style format.

But rather than us all sitting at home, knowing that the Foreign Affairs Minister will face no consequences for his actions, the people of Cork could be out at the ballot box today, giving their own view on the matter. It will likely be another three years before the people decide if they want Minister Coveney representing their constituency, and even more likely to be a lot longer until there is a system to recall a political representative in Ireland, if ever.

While Newsom looks likely to escape any consequences for breaking the rules he imposed on the people of California, at least Californians have a say as to whether or not his actions justify him being removed from his position, whereas in Ireland we only get to remove our political representatives every 5 – 7 years during the election cycle.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sinn Féin Pre-Election Analysis

  Operating off the recent in-depth RedC poll, while taking other recent polls into account, one thing is certain, Sinn Féin will have a time-machine on the top of their list to Santa if the election isn’t called before Christmas. It seems like it was only yesterday when the party was polling in the mid-30s, reaching a high of 36%, and seemed like a government in waiting if they managed to get some smaller parties and independents on board. What must have been a scramble for candidates to even get within a whiff of a majority, now some tough decisions will have to be made as to whether they will even run a second candidate in some constituencies. Keep in mind that in some constituencies where the polled well in 2020, and were polling very well in polls, such as Donegal, Cavan-Monaghan, and Louth, there were rumours of a third candidate being added in the 5-seater constituencies where they were polling close to 50% of the vote. When once there were talks of 60+ seats, now they...
Post a Comment
Read more

Book Review : Animal Farm by George Orwell

  BOOK REVIEW : ANIMAL FARM   There is no doubt that George Orwell’s classic Animal Farm will divide opinions depending on what side of the political spectrum that you stand on, and your understanding of late imperial and early soviet Russian history. I tried to put the historical reflection to the back of my mind while reading this book, and as a historian it was rather difficult. Some of the analogies were downright wrong, many were open to interpretation, and some were fair. What I gathered about the author from this read was that he was a diehard Trotskyist, eulogising the assassinated liberal-left ideologist in the form of Snowball the pig, and Communist leader Vladimir Lenin in the form of Major the pig; while vilifying Josef Stalin in his depiction as tyrant pig Napoleon. While the pigs represent Soviet leadership, the dogs represent the Soviet Army and Police, and the other animals the general workers of the USSR. I would argue that more time is spent vilify...
Post a Comment
Read more

Rebelling Against The 1% One Beer At A Time

If you're heading to the pub this weekend, then you may have an important choice to make, do you want to join a rebellion? Across Ireland, and indeed across many parts of the world, a beer revolution is taking place in the form of Craft Beer. Local breweries are popping up across the map, and are offering beer drinkers the chance to support business in their own areas. For many years the choice was between national or international beers, such as choosing between Guinness and Budweiser, but now many pubs have a choice between beers brewed by local entrepreneurs or big corporations. Local breweries produce small quantities of beer that are described as craft made, with special attention given to each batch, and the best part is that the profits go to local people, rather than to investors scattered around the globe. The idea of supporting local has many positives; it's more environmentally friendly as the beer is transported a very short distance, is supports local jobs, and...
Post a Comment
Read more