Skip to main content

Elitism Prevails

 



Elitism Prevails

 

In 2013 the people of Ireland voted to retain our second house of democracy, Seanad Éireann; but it was a narrow victory and was predicated by a general understanding that the Irish electorate wanted to see this pathetic resemblance of democracy to be seriously reformed. Nine years later, that elitism that was promised to be rid from our flawed democracy is still thriving.

Next month, March 2022, we will see a by-election for a Seanad seat that was vacated by the Labour Party’s Ivana Bacik when she was elected to the only truly democratic house in the state, Dáil Éireann. But despite an electorate in the millions, only some 60,000 people will be granted the privilege of voting; graduates from Trinity College Dublin, an institute with a deep history of elitism and sectarianism.

Of the sixty seats in the Seanad, graduates of TCD have the privilege of voting for three of those Seanadóirí, and the combined institutes that form the National Universities of Ireland elect another three. Eleven are hand-picked by the Taoiseach of the day, and the remaining forty-three are elected by serving politicians.

I am a second-class graduate, without the privilege of partaking in a part of our democratic process, because I decided to attend the second-class university, the University of Limerick.

But why should someone have to graduate from a certain university in order to have a vote? A barrister who studied law at Trinity College is represented by not one, not two, but three Seanadóirí; while an engineer who studied at Limerick IT ( now TUS), has zero representation.

There has been talks since the 2013 referendum of extending this privilege to graduates of all universities, but that is merely a slightly expanded elitism; reminiscent of elite, wealthy Catholics being allowed to take a seat in Westminster, so long as they swore allegiance to a foreign monarchy and behaved themselves. Granting me and my fellow graduates of UL a vote, isn’t going to fix the problem, nor will it make me any less eager to seek democracy in our second house of parliament.

We live in a country where only those who went to a prestigious university are allowed to vote in our Seanad, while most Gardaí, nurses, soldiers, builders, carpenters, plumbers, retail workers, drivers, civil servants, are denied that opportunity to vote in the Seanad.

Now I will say, and it’s likely no secret to you, that I put my name forward for convention to the Seanad, and as a politician I did have a vote in the 2016 Seanad election. That doesn’t change my opinion of the institution, or anything that I have said above. Had I made it to the chamber, one of the first things I would have spoken about is exactly what I have said above.

The Seanad was meticulously designed to be this way, to prevent ordinary people from ever gaining power, or at the very least acting as a serious disruptor to change. This could come true if there is a General Election before the next Local Elections; should Sinn Féin (currently set to be the largest party), comes into government, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael will still control the Seanad and be able to seriously disrupt Sinn Féin’s plan for government. In that scenario, on a good day at the polls, Sinn Féin would be lucky to come away with 20 out of the 60 seats, despite being the largest party in the Dáil.

I truly hope that this Seanad by-election for Trinity College is the last of it’s kind, and that some form of democracy will be brought to that institution that is supposed to be democratic. Now is the opportunity to talk about turning voting from a privilege into a right, and ensure that true reform that was promised by the Fine Gael- Labour government in 2013 is finally delivered.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What's The Beef With Beef ?

The Irish Beef Industry has been going through turbulent times recently, most notably because of the proposed Mercosur deal and the prices farmers receive for their cattle. We haven't even reached Brexit yet, and are still weeks out from the latest withdrawal deadline, and beef farmers are at their wits end. But how has it got to this and can farmers cope if there is a no-deal Brexit? Farmers' incomes are under threat, not just because of the reasons outlined above, but also because of the threat to grants which keep small and medium farms in business. The recent EU elections have seen the status quo remain in the European Parliament, with parties of the right keeping their large dominance of the union. There has been some debate surrounding the EU's agricultural plan over the course of the previous five year parliament, particularly regarding the EU's farm subsidy. Now that the elections are over, the EU government could proceed with plans which could see a standard ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Sinn Féin Pre-Election Analysis

  Operating off the recent in-depth RedC poll, while taking other recent polls into account, one thing is certain, Sinn Féin will have a time-machine on the top of their list to Santa if the election isn’t called before Christmas. It seems like it was only yesterday when the party was polling in the mid-30s, reaching a high of 36%, and seemed like a government in waiting if they managed to get some smaller parties and independents on board. What must have been a scramble for candidates to even get within a whiff of a majority, now some tough decisions will have to be made as to whether they will even run a second candidate in some constituencies. Keep in mind that in some constituencies where the polled well in 2020, and were polling very well in polls, such as Donegal, Cavan-Monaghan, and Louth, there were rumours of a third candidate being added in the 5-seater constituencies where they were polling close to 50% of the vote. When once there were talks of 60+ seats, now they...
Post a Comment
Read more

Recall and No Confidence

  By the time you are reading this, it is likely that California Governor Gavin Newsom will either have survived a recall election, or will have been removed as Governor. But the timing of the election, the same day as Irish Foreign Affairs Minister Simon Coveney faces what is almost certain to be an unsuccessful motion of no confidence, and it begs the question, ‘Should Ireland have a recall process?’ For those unaware of the process, following incompetence or scandal (Governor Newsom was caught breaking his own COVID rules, sound familiar?), the minimum of 12% of the California electorate signed a petition to hold a recall election, which is composed of two parts. Firstly will Newsom stay or go, which requires 50% approval (he was elected with 62% of the vote), and if the electorate choose for him to go, then Part II of the ballot will come into effect, who will replace him? A motion of no confidence usually requires the government of the day to turn against one of their ow...
Post a Comment
Read more